fracasos de la política americana, El American

American Policy Failures with Putin

Relations between democracies and dictatorships should be lukewarm at best, but never one of friendship, trust, or economic entanglement

[Leer en español]

Republican and Democratic administrations have misread Vladimir Putin’s kleptocratic regime. The West, in general, has diagrammed policy towards post-Soviet Russia under false perceptions. Sun Tzu’s notion that, “If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat,” (The Art of War) has epitomized the Free World’s course following the collapse of the USSR.

The fall of Soviet communism produced a euphoria in the West. Rightly so. The wholesale theft of Eastern and Central Europe by the Soviet Union following World War II, the ascent of Chinese communism, and the invasion of South Korea by the North, prompted a comprehensive Western reaction to challenge the malignancy of communism. Why did the West assume Russia would transition into a democracy?

George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton inherited the dividend of the Reagan Doctrine. Capitalism, as the West’s premier socioeconomic model, played an important role in sinking socialism. However, it was not the only factor. The morality inherent in Western values were paramount instruments. Ideology mattered. America and the international liberal order that emerged after the defeat of National Socialism in Europe was not just about economics. 

The transition following the breakup of the Soviet Union contained suspicious elements from the beginning. The 1990s in Russia witnessed the biggest privatization program in history. The massive transfer of state-owned enterprises (SOE) into private hands proved to be a deceitful ploy. It was legalized theft. The managers of those very SOEs ended up “selling” to themselves these assets. With state subsidized credit, regulated low prices, shares and voucher schemes, a newly formed oligarchic class with political ties to power and the Soviet past was consolidated. Elections lost their competitiveness, as the kleptocracy rigged the political system.

Under these conditions, Clinton signed the 1994 Budapest Memorandum which made the U.S. a guarantor of Ukraine’s sovereignty, in exchange for the surrender of their nuclear arsenal, then the world’s third largest. How could Clinton trust Russia? After all, it was clear by then that Boris Yeltsin had done a superb job in dismantling the USSR, but a feeble one in establishing a democracy.

How many people signed the Declaration of Independence?*
This poll gives you free access to our premium politics newsletter. Unsubscribe at any time.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

The Islamic attacks of September 11 lead George W Bush to see Putin as an ally. He went so far as to publicly say in 2001 that he had seen Putin’s soul and was convinced of his honesty. One wonders if Russia’s invasion of Georgia in 2008 changed Bush’s mind. Judging from the West’s reaction to this brutal aggression, Putin continued to be a stealth thug.    

Barack Obama was, by far, the biggest dupe for the Putin regime. The actions of his two presidential terms empowered the Russian dictator in unprecedented ways. The dismantling of the nascent Europe defensive missile system, denying arms sales to Ukraine and torpedoing its NATO entry, authorizing American uranium access rights, and a “red-line” invitation in Syria, were all overtures to Putin for a failed “reset” policy. In the 2012 elections, as Obama debated, Mitt Romney, he ridiculed the Republican candidate for suggesting Putin was a threat to the West. The Obama Doctrine turned out to be an appeasement treatise that galvanized Russian adventurism. 

Putin’s invasion of Ukraine in 2014 was met with weakness and moral ambivalence by Obama. This validated Russia’s blatant claim that, in some absurd manner, it had a sphere of influence “right” to pulverize Ukrainian sovereignty. At that moment, the Western international liberal order that was built after the Second World War, was formally buried. Russian cyber-attacks, the election meddling, and the Havana Syndrome, were only some manifestations of Putin’s imperialist endeavors that would follow.      

Donald Trump, despite some of his reckless public statements, was the president who caused the most damage to the Putin regime. The bombings in Syria that killed Russian soldiers and arms sales to Ukraine, along with the training of its military, directly challenged Russian dictatorial interests. However, it was the remarkable increase in American oil production that most hurt Putin’s war machine. 

Fossil-fuel sales revenues, as was the case with the USSR, remains Russia’s key to hard currency entry. Collapsing oil prices, resulting from the increase in supply under Trump’s watch, was a financial blow to the Eurasian kleptocracy. Coincidently, this was part of Reagan’s strategy to rollback Soviet communism. Words and symbols, however, are vital in politics. Trump erred by stubbornly refusing to address Putin as a dictator. This played into the Left’s narrative. It also helped Putin. 

The 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine has opened a new chapter in American and European foreign policy. The West must partner with the free exclusively.     

Previous Article
musk biden

Biden’s and Musk’s Approaches to Speech Censorship

Next Article
EEUU permite entrada a cientos de migrantes de albergues de Tijuana (México) San Diego, 4 de may (EFE).- Una coalición de organizaciones de la frontera de California consiguió que el Gobierno de Estados Unidos dejara pasar a cientos de migrantes que han esperado oportunidad para solicitar asilo en albergues de Tijuana (México), informó a Efe la organización Border Angels.  La directora ejecutiva del grupo, Dulce García, dijo que unos 300 migrantes de albergues que apoya su organización en Tijuana han cruzado hasta el momento la frontera.  Subrayó que a principios de abril, su organización sostuvo un encuentro virtual con los directores de 17 albergues, en su mayoría de Tijuana, para preguntarles qué es lo que querían que ella informara al Departamento de Seguridad Nacional (DHS).  Todos los directores dijeron que querían que se reabriera el proceso de asilo, señaló.  "El 18 de abril, cuando Border Angels se reunió con funcionarios de DHS, ellos aceptaron. Nos dieron la oportunidad de cruzar algunos solicitantes de asilo cada día, una noticia que llenó de alegría a los directores del albergue", dijo García.  Entonces se reactivó una agrupación que en 2001 había conseguido que cruzaran con libertad condicional humanitaria cerca de un millar de migrantes, la Alianza Humanitaria El Chaparral (CHA, en inglés).  Con esta colaboración de CHA han presentado a la Oficina de Aduanas y Protección Fronteriza (CBP) más de 300 personas, dijo García.  Agregó que los nombres de los migrantes que cruzarán los próximos días ya fueron identificados y no habrá oportunidad de incluir a más personas para que sean procesadas, a menos de que el gobierno estadounidense restaure el proceso de asilo.  Ahora que llegan más migrantes a los albergues en Tijuana, la coalición les informa que la frontera sigue cerrada para solicitantes de asilo, y que no hay lista de espera.  "Nosotros lamentamos muchísimo que solo algunas personas lleguen a cruzar la frontera, mientras tantas otras se quedarán viviendo en riesgo, a menos que en realidad termine la implementación de Título 42 y se restaure el proceso de asilo", dijo García.  El Título 42, que devuelve de forma expedita a los inmigrantes en la frontera, fue puesto en marcha en marzo de 2020 para detener el flujo migratorio argumentando los riesgos de la pandemia de la covid-19.  El gobierno de Joe Biden anunció que el 23 de mayo suspendería el uso de esta medida, a la cual recurrió su predecesor Donald Trump hace dos años y por la cual unos 1,7 millones de migrantes han sido expulsados en la frontera sur.  Sin embargo, un juez federal en Louisiana ordenó una suspensión temporal de la decisión del gobierno y fijó una audiencia para el 13 de mayo en la cual se determinará si puede rescindirse el Título 42.

Biden Admin. Allows Hundreds of Migrants to Cross Border from Mexican Shelters

Related Posts